Engage Louisa is a nonpartisan newsletter that keeps folks informed about Louisa County government. We believe our community is stronger and our government serves us better when we increase transparency, accessibility, and engagement.
This week in county government: public meetings, May 4 through May 9
For the latest information on county meetings, including public meetings of boards, commissions, authorities, work groups, and internal county committees, click here.
Monday, May 4
Louisa County Board of Supervisors, Public Meeting Room, Louisa County Office Building, 1 Woolfolk Ave., Louisa, 6 pm. The board will convene in closed session at 5 pm. (agenda packet, livestream)
Tuesday, May 5
Louisa County School Board, Central Office Administration Building, 953 Davis Highway, Mineral, 7 pm. (agenda, livestream)
Thursday, May 7
Agricultural, Forestal and Rural Preservation Committee, Public Meeting Room, Louisa County Office Building, 1 Woolfolk Ave., Louisa, 7 pm. (agenda packet)
Quote of the week
“We were intentional [in bringing data centers to the county]. We did this, and I will wear this like a badge of honor. I will not let people beat me up over it.”
-Jackson District Supervisor Toni Williams at the board’s April 27 meeting, defending county leaders’ effort to lure controversial data center development. Read more below.
BOS roundup: Supervisors adopt $201 million budget for FY27, cut personal property tax rate; Williams defends data center development
The Louisa County Board of Supervisors last Monday voted unanimously to slice the county’s personal property tax rate by 15 percent, lowering the levy on cars, trucks, boats and other vehicles from $2.43 per $100 of assessed value to $2.07. (meeting materials, video)
Supervisors touted the move as a dividend of their efforts to attract economic development—namely data centers—which they say will bulk up the tax base and deliver much-needed revenue to pay for county services. They’ve suggested more tax relief is on the way.
“This board and a previous board have been very active in getting what I believe is smart economic development in this county that will help shift the tax burden from residential homeowners and personal property taxes to the businesses that invest here,” Board Chair and Mineral District Supervisor Duane Adams said.
Jackson District Supervisor Toni Williams who, along with Adams, serves on the board’s finance committee, agreed.
“We’ve been attracting data centers intentionally. The citizens should see something for that. This is just the beginning of what I hope we are going to be able to share and do for the citizens,” Williams said.
The tax cut is part of a larger budget package that the board advanced for the fiscal year that starts July 1. That includes a $201 million spending plan with $186.4 million allotted for operations and maintenance and $14.6 million slated for capital projects.
The operating budget covers the daily costs of running county government, paying for everything from employees’ salaries to fuel for fire trucks, while the Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) covers long-lasting and big-ticket items like new school buildings, ambulances and infrastructure projects.
As part of the plan, the board retained a real estate tax rate of 72 cents per $100 of assessed value, the same rate the county’s had for about a decade and among the lowest in the area. But even though the rate won’t change, many homeowners will see their tax bills rise, a consequence of an uptick in assessments.
The assessed value of real estate, excluding new construction and improvements, rose an average of 6.88 percent this year, meaning a resident whose home is assessed at $400,000 and increased in value in line with the county average, will pay about $180 more than last year.
Since 2022, the assessed value of real estate has jumped about 48 percent countywide, causing most homeowners’ real estate taxes to soar. That’s prompted some community members to urge the board to slash the tax rate to offset the increase in assessments. The board would’ve had to lower the rate more than four cents to counter this year’s rise in property values.
Supervisors have resisted those calls, contending that increased revenue from real estate taxes helps cover the rising cost of county services, driven by inflation and population growth. They’ve also said that they’d prefer to keep the tax rate stable to avoid an annual political fight.
The board, in the last four years, has twice opted to issue modest real estate tax rebates to mitigate the pain of rising taxes. But board members chose to forgo a rebate this year in favor of the rate reduction on personal property.
Adams and Williams have touted the rate cut as the potential first step to eliminating personal property taxes for individuals over the next few years. If that happens, it will come via a combination of rate cuts and rebates due to a provision in state law that prohibits localities from lowering the personal property tax rate for individuals below the rate for businesses. The latter rate sits at $1.90 per $100.
Adams said on Monday that, as revenue from data centers ramps up in the coming years, he hopes to couple cuts in personal property taxes with real estate tax rebates. But he said he wouldn’t support reducing the real estate tax rate outright because the county can’t tax residences and businesses separately. It can extend rebates exclusively to homeowners though.
“We can rebate residences while the commercial development continues to pay the full rate,” Adams said.
As the three data center campuses currently under construction are built out over the next 15 years, the county will derive revenue from real estate taxes on the buildings and land and business personal property taxes on data center equipment. The county taxes the equipment at $1.25 per $100.
Cuckoo District Supervisor Chris McCotter, whose district includes the lower end of Lake Anna where real estate assessments and, in turn, tax bills, have skyrocketed over the last few years, said earlier in the budget process that he polled his constituents and most respondents preferred a rebate on their real estate taxes to lower personal property taxes. But McCotter didn’t publicly push for a rebate at Monday’s meeting.
After adopting the budget last year, McCotter expressed frustration with the processes the county uses to craft the spending plan and conduct assessments, saying in a Facebook post last May that it would be the last budget he’d vote for unless there were changes.
Before joining his colleagues to unanimously approve next year’s budget, McCotter acknowledged those remarks, claiming that he’d been looking for ways to make the budget process more transparent and crediting three “budget roadshows”—informal meetings held in different parts of the county to discuss the budget with residents—in achieving that goal.
“I’m pleased now with the budget process, and those concerns have been addressed. Specifically, I wanted to evaluate ways to make the budget process even more transparent, and I am pleased to say that, through the budget roadshows, I feel like budget transparency was never stronger,” he said.
McCotter didn’t address the assessment process, which is handled by the county assessor’s office. The assessor bases its valuations on market values and, by state law, operates independent of the board of supervisors.
Aside from the budget roadshows, which drew less than 20 community members across three meetings, the budget process appeared to deviate little from previous years. The board’s Finance Committee, along with County Administrator Christian Goodwin and Finance Director Wanda Colvin, did most of the heavy lifting in crafting the budget and their recommendations received little scrutiny—at least publicly—from other board members.
Across about five hours of budget work sessions this winter and spring, the board had limited conversation about the bulk of county spending, mostly discussing how to allocate funding for outside agencies, which comprises a tiny fraction of the budget.
In a shift from recent years, the school division, sheriff’s office and Fire and EMS Department presented high-level overviews of their budget requests. But the presentations didn’t result in detailed public discussion among board members or county staff about how the agencies plan to spend more than $131 million of taxpayer money, their collective share of next year’s operating budget.
To read more about the budget, check out the last two editions of Engage Louisa here and here. Check out the draft budget here.
Williams delivers full-throated defense of data center development
As concerns about data center development grow in Louisa County and beyond, one member of the board of supervisors defended local leaders’ efforts to lure the industry, saying that he considers bringing data centers to the county a “badge of honor” and, one day, residents will be grateful.
“We were intentional [in bringing data center development to the county]. We did this, and I will wear this like a badge of honor. I will not let people beat me up over it…We are going to own this. We are going to wear it, and we are not going to back up,” Jackson District Supervisor Toni Williams said at Monday’s meeting, flanked by the board’s other six members.
Williams, a Republican who’s been on the board for more than a decade, said the three data center campuses that are either under development or slated to be—Amazon Web Services’ (AWS) campuses by the North Anna Power Station and Northeast Creek Reservoir and EdgeCore Digital Infrastructure’s complex at the Shannon Hill Regional Business Park—could produce more tax revenue annually than the county’s current operating budget, which topped $175 million for this fiscal year.
He said that, as the campuses are built out, the revenue would allow county leaders to reduce the tax burden on citizens, touting the board’s vote to cut the personal property tax rate by 15 percent earlier in the meeting as the first step toward significant tax relief.
The county will derive revenue from the campuses from real estate taxes on the buildings and land and business personal property taxes on the pricey computer equipment inside. That revenue is expected to escalate as the warehouse-like facilities are constructed over the next 15 years though at least 15 percent will be returned to the tech companies based on their level of capital investment.
“We intend on passing this [revenue] through and making sure it counts towards the taxes that individuals in this county have to pay. We got a small deposit on that tonight,” Williams said.
Williams acknowledged that some residents are dealing with negative impacts from data center development right now, a consequence of ongoing construction. But he insisted, the facilities are going to pay big dividends in the long run.
“I attribute this to just like the [North Anna] nuclear power plant was in the late ‘60s and early ‘70s. We are going to look back at a time from now, and we are going to be grateful it’s here,” he said.
Williams’ comments come as residents have expressed growing worries about data centers, from their impact on the county’s rural character to its infrastructure.
Community members have voiced concern that the power-hungry and water-guzzling buildings, which power cloud computing and artificial intelligence, will drain the public water supply and raise their power bills. They’ve also decried the onslaught of heavy truck traffic on rural roads, a consequence of a years-long construction process, and argued that noise and light pollution will continue to hinder their quality of life once the campuses are finished.
But Williams mostly brushed off those worries, arguing that if Louisa hadn’t opened the door to data centers, tech companies would just set up shop in a neighboring locality. That, he suggested, would leave the county to deal with the negative consequences, like new transmission lines to deliver power, sans the benefits of increased tax revenue.
“We were intentional. We went after data centers. What about the electricity? That’s not my problem…If we don’t get [data center development] here, Goochland’s going to take it. Hanover’s going to take it…and they’re still going to have to provide electricity to them,” he said.
Williams also minimized public opposition to the facilities, especially in his district where no data center campuses are planned.
“There are 43,000 people in the county, and the most I’ve ever seen in one gathering against anything is about 100. And, I’ll be honest with you, not too many of them come from the Jackson District,” he said.
While none of his colleagues directly responded to Williams’ comments, Mineral District Supervisor Duane Adams hailed the anticipated impact of data center revenue earlier in the meeting. He called the facilities currently in the works “smart economic development,” contending that they’ve opened the door to lower taxes for residents in the years to come.
Though few Jackson District residents have weighed in on data center development at public meetings, community members took to social media last week to express displeasure with Williams’ comments. Several people in the Bumpass Residents’ Facebook Group said that community members need to vote Williams out, along other supervisors who back data centers.
“Toni Williams needs to get on the [Facebook] groups and listen to his constituents. No one wants the data centers here. We, as a community, need to vote the supervisors off of the board that are pushing for the data centers to protect our land, electricity, and health,” one commenter said.
Others wondered why their real estate taxes continue to climb even as Williams promises an onslaught of revenue from data centers. The board has adopted the same real estate tax rate of 72-cent per $100 of assessed value for the last decade, but many homeowners have seen their tax bills soar due to rising assessments.
“Nobody’s going to be grateful. We’re still paying more taxes with the real estate assessment jump. Why do we keep voting these guys back into office?” another commenter said.
Opinions about data centers in Louisa seem to reflect broader concerns about the industry across Virginia. The state is home to more data centers than anywhere else in world.
According to a recent poll from The Washington Post and the Schar School of Policy and Government at George Mason University, only 35 percent of Virginians say they’re comfortable with a new data center coming to their community. Only 41 percent believe data centers positively impact local government funding while just 20 percent think data centers positively impact property taxes. More than two-thirds of respondents say they oppose extending a state sales tax exemption for data center companies that meet certain investment requirements.
Lawmakers in Richmond are struggling to finalize a biennial state budget as they haggle over whether to ax the exemption, which has helped make Virginia the global epicenter of the data center industry. Williams appeared to allude to the budget fight—and the perceived importance of the exemption for continued data center development—in his comments on Monday.
“[The tax revenue] numbers [the county could get from data centers] are staggering,” he said, “if the General Assembly doesn’t screw this up.”
Supes add nearly 3,000 acres to Agricultural and Forestal Districts
Supervisors on Monday held public hearings and voted unanimously to green-light the addition of nearly 3,000 acres to Agricultural and Forestal Districts.
AFDs are a conservation tool that allow landowners to voluntarily prohibit development on their property for 10-year periods. In return, participating parcels are assured enrollment in the Use Value Taxation program, colloquially referred to as “land use.” The program places a special assessment on land used for agriculture, horticulture or forestry based on its “use value,” instead of its fair market value, translating into substantially lower tax bills.
In addition, AFDs place restrictions on local governments’ ability to enact ordinances that “would unreasonably restrict or regulate farm structures or farming and forestry practices,” per state code. They also offer participating parcels limited protection from the use of eminent domain—the ability of government and public utilities to acquire private land for public use.
AFDs have emerged as a key tool in the county’s effort to preserve working rural lands because they provide an opportunity to press pause on development amid burgeoning residential and industrial growth. The districts also help keep large tracts of land intact, thanks to restrictions on divisions and subdivisions.
With Monday’s action, the board expanded five of the county’s 14 AFDs by a combined 2,968 acres, tacking on 2,047 acres to the Ellisville AFD north and west of the Town of Louisa; adding roughly 402 acres to the Gold Mine Creek AFD in northwestern Louisa; expanding the South Anna AFD in south-central Louisa by 413 acres; increasing the Taylors Creek AFD in the southeastern end of the county by about 80 acres; and adding 25 acres to the Indian Creek AFD, also in southeastern Louisa.
The county’s AFD program has grown by about 3,100 acres since the board last September hired Maggie Brakeville as the county’s first agricultural development and land conservation coordinator. Another 2,100 acres are expected to be added over the next couple months, pending board approval.
Board Chair Duane Adams praised Brakeville’s efforts to grow the program. “You’re doing a really great job, so I wanted to commend you on that,” Adams said.
Other business
Supes move five LCPS capital projects to FY26: Supervisors voted unanimously to move $305,000 earmarked for five capital projects requested by Louisa County Public Schools from the Fiscal Year 2027 Capital Improvement Plan to the budget for this fiscal year. The school board asked supervisors to fund the projects early so they can be completed before the start of the next academic year. They include $140,000 for cafeteria equipment; $75,000 for parking lot repairs and additions; $50,000 for field repairs and replacement; $25,000 for carpet and flooring; and $15,000 for classroom furniture. The money will be drawn from the schools’ long-term capital reserves.
Board approves county’s participation in proposed opioid-related settlement agreement: Supervisors voted unanimously to approve the county’s participation in a proposed settlement agreement in a class action lawsuit against six pharmaceutical distributors related to their role in the opioid epidemic. The companies, collectively known as the Six Remnant Defendants, agreed to pay more than $97 million to participating local governments for opioid abatement initiatives. By agreeing to participate in the settlement, Louisa County will get .00977 percent of the money, according to County Attorney Patricia Smith, minus attorneys’ fees.
Board authorizes use of TOT revenue for tourism related expenses: Supervisors greenlit the allocation of $85,160 for tourism related expenses. Of that, $71,000 is earmarked for the Louisa Arts Center and $14,160 is slated for the Louisa County Historical Society (LCHS). The arts center plans to use its money for event costs, including performer fees, and to support the upcoming Queen Legacy concert. The society plans to spend its allocation on programming supplies and advertising and marketing, among other event-related expenses. The money will come from the Transient Occupancy Tax (TOT), a seven percent levy tacked on to visitors’ bills when they stay the night at a hotel, bed and breakfast or short-term rental. Per state law, a portion of the money generated by the tax must be used for tourism-related expenses.
Board to consider broadening tax relief program for elderly, disabled; BOS expected to allocate funding to fight proposed 765-kV power line
The Louisa County Board of Supervisors on Monday night will convene for its first May meeting with three public hearings on tap. Here’s a preview.
BOS to consider expanding tax relief program for elderly and disabled
Supervisors on Monday will hold a public hearing and consider changes to a program that offers real estate tax relief to income-eligible elderly and disabled residents. The tweaks would slightly raise the annual income cap to participate, and adjust the sliding scale that determines how much relief a household qualifies for.
Currently, the program provides real estate tax relief to totally disabled residents and residents 65 years old and over whose combined household income falls at or below $50,000 a year and whose net worth, excluding their home and 10 acres, falls at or below $200,000. It caps the amount of tax relief annually available to participating households at $3,000.
The county provides the relief based on a sliding scale. Residents with a combined household income up to $18,000 and with a net worth up to $70,000 are eligible for an up to 100 percent exemption. At the other end of the scale, residents who make between $40,001 and $50,000 a year and whose net worth is between $150,001 and $200,000 are eligible for an up to 45 percent tax break.
The proposed changes, which were recommended by staff and the board’s Finance Committee, would increase to $55,000 the program’s annual income limit and up the income thresholds that, in part, determine how much tax relief residents get.
For example, households with an annual income of up to $19,800 and a net worth of $70,000 or less would be eligible for 100 percent tax relief while residents who make between $44,001 and $55,000 and have a net worth between $150,001 and $200,000 would get a 45 percent reduction. The amount of relief would still be capped at $3,000 a year.
The proposed tweaks are aimed at easing the burden of rising real estate taxes on some of the county’s most vulnerable residents.
Though the board has maintained a level real estate tax rate of 72 cents per $100 of assessed value for about a decade, many homeowners have seen their tax bills soar in the face of rising assessments. The assessed value of the county’s real estate, excluding new construction and improvements, has jumped about 48 percent since 2022. It climbed, on average, 6.88 percent this year.
During the last several budget cycles, many residents have urged the board to slash the tax rate to offset the increase in assessments, contending their rising taxes are unsustainable. But supervisors have resisted those calls and instead opted for more modest and targeted tax relief.
The board has broadened the tax relief program three times in the last five years. Over the last few years, supervisors have increased by $2,000 the maximum tax break allowed under the program.
Finance Director Wanda Colvin said at the Finance Committee meeting late last month that she isn’t sure how the proposed changes to the program would impact the county’s Fiscal Year 2027 budget because it’s unclear how many more residents will qualify for relief and how many will be eligible for a larger tax break.
Supervisors last week adopted a $201 million spending plan for FY27. They’ll formally appropriate the budget on Monday night.
To learn more about the tax relief program, call the Commissioner of the Revenue’s Office at 540-967-3432.
Supervisors expected to allocate $250k to fight proposed Joshua Falls to Yeat transmission line
Though the item isn’t on the board’s advertised agenda, supervisors on Monday night are expected to allocate $250,000 to fight Valley Link Transmission Company’s proposed Joshua Falls to Yeat transmission line.
If approved by state regulators, the 115-mile, 765-kilovolt (kV) power line would slice through as many as nine mostly rural localities, including Louisa, delivering electricity generated in the Ohio River Valley to power-hungry users in Northern and Central Virginia, especially data centers.
Board Chair Duane Adams confirmed to Engage Louisa that supervisors are set to add the allocation to the agenda at Monday’s meeting and earmark the money to help cover legal expenses to support efforts to block the line and press the State Corporation Commission (SCC) to consider alternatives. The commission ultimately has the power to approve the infrastructure.
The line has sparked widespread opposition from residents in Louisa and the eight other potentially impacted localities—Fluvanna, Buckingham, Orange, Spotsylvania, Culpeper, Goochland, Appomattox and Campbell—with some arguing that rural land is being sacrificed to feed data development to the north.
Valley Link, a joint venture between Dominion Energy, FirstEnergy Transmission and Transource, announced plans to build the line earlier this year. Dominion and its partners say the line, which would require a cleared 200-foot right-of-way and poles as high as 160 feet every quarter mile, is necessary to meet the burgeoning demand for power across the region and to stabilize the grid.
Valley Link has shared two potential corridors for the line and a handful of variations. The proposed routes cut through farms and forestland and pass by neighborhoods and schools en route from the Joshua Falls substation in Campbell to the proposed Yeat substation in southeastern Culpeper.
Valley Link plans to settle on a single preferred route in the coming months and submit its plan to the SCC for approval in September. At that point, stakeholders, including impacted localities, will have an opportunity to make their case for why the company’s proposal isn’t the right fit and to present alternatives.
Louisa and several localities have made clear that they plan to take their fight to the SCC, potentially as a united front. County leaders from eight of the potentially impacted counties gathered for a summit in Louisa in early April to strategize about ways they could work together to oppose the project. While no concrete plans for regional cooperation have been publicly shared, Louisa County said in a press release that the meeting “highlighted a willingness to cooperate regionally.”
In a sign that a regional coalition could be taking shape, Louisa, Fluvanna, Goochland, Orange and Culpeper last week filed a Joint Motion to Intervene and Protest in a case pending before the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) that could potentially play a role Valley Link’s effort to secure approval for the line.
Louisa isn’t the only locality that’s ponying up money to fund its opposition. The Goochland County Board of Supervisors last month allocated $250,000 for the same purpose. In a press release, the county said that the money would be used for a range of initiatives, including “collaboration with community members who have offered to assist the Board and the engagement of professional and technical experts to advise the Board.”
“These efforts are intended to ensure that Goochland County’s interests are clearly represented and that potential impacts to the community are thoroughly evaluated,” the release said.
Aside from the anticipated action on Monday night, Louisa County officials have taken other steps to advocate against the project. Supervisors last month passed a resolution expressing strong opposition to the roughly 20-mile segment proposed to traverse the county.
In addition, local officials are preparing to approve an addendum to the county’s Comprehensive Plan that articulates guidelines for future transmission infrastructure. The guidelines prioritize the use of existing utility corridors as well as public right of ways along roads. They also encourage new transmission line corridors to avoid or minimize impacts on residential areas, agricultural and forestal lands, scenic and environmental resources, conservation easements and historic sites.
A county’s Comprehensive Plan is a long-range planning document that lays out a vision for future development, establishing guidelines for land use, infrastructure and public services. Per state law, the SCC is required to consider proposed transmission lines’ conformance with local comp plans when deciding whether to green-light projects.
The planning commission will hold a public hearing on the addendum at its May 14 meeting while the board of supervisors will consider the item at its May 18 meeting.
Supes to consider CUP for farmers’ market near Zion Crossroads
A farmers’ market could be coming to Zion Crossroads.
Supervisors will hold a public hearing and consider whether to approve Zion United Methodist Church’s request for a conditional use permit (CUP) to operate a year-round farmers’ market in the church’s parking lot at 1674 Zion Road.
The 5.68-acre parcel is zoned agricultural and straddles the boundary of the Zion Crossroads Growth Area Overlay District.
Per a set of “Guiding Procedures” prepared by the church, the market would operate only on Saturdays, opening no earlier than 10 am and closing no later than 4 pm. It would have no more than 13 vendors and offer free food distribution via the church’s food pantry. The church would also abide by a county-approved parking plan.
Pastor David McWilliams told the planning commission at its March meeting that he envisions the market as a space to foster community.
“More so than just being a market, we’d want to be a third space for community. A third space is basically a place where a community gathers outside of home and work,” McWilliams said, adding that the church hopes to bring in food trucks, use its playgrounds and host live music.
McWilliams noted that the church would likely host the market only on select Saturdays and during warmer months, but it’s asking for permission to hold a weekly market year-round so the event has room to grow.
Community Development Department staff recommended 11 conditions as part of the CUP, including that the church adhere to the “Guiding Procedures” submitted as part of its application, prohibit fireworks and amplified outdoor music and bar vendors peddling mass produced or multi-level marketing items.
The commission voted unanimously to recommend that supervisors approve the CUP.
Board to hold public hearing on VDOT’s six-year secondary road plan
Supervisors will hold a public hearing and consider approval of the Six-Year Plan for Secondary Road System Construction in Louisa County.
Developed in cooperation with the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT), the plan covers road improvements in the secondary system from 2026-27 through 2031-32, earmarking between $171,356 and $254,457 a year for improvements for a total projected allocation of roughly $1.366 million.
The funds are drawn from the state’s Rural Rustic Program, which is specifically aimed at improving or paving unpaved public roads that carry more than 50 vehicles per day, and “telefee” funds, money paid by telecommunications companies that use public right of ways.
The plan earmarks funding to upgrade or improve several unpaved roads and for traffic and engineering services, including speed studies, signage and incidental work.
The plan includes funding to pave or improve parts of the following roads over the next five years: West Green Springs Road; Harts Mill Road; Poplar Avenue; New Anna Road; Thurston Road; Turners Mill Road; Old Bickley Town Road; and Two County Lane.
Other business
Supervisors to appropriate FY27 budget: After adopting the Fiscal Year 2027 budget last week, supervisors on Monday night will formally appropriate $186.4 million to cover the daily costs of running county government in the coming fiscal year and $14.6 million for capital projects.
Supervisors to hear presentation from Louisa County Historical Society: Supervisors will hear a presentation from the Louisa County Historical Society. The nonprofit organization is set to receive $24,000 in county support as part of the FY27 budget.
Louisa Town Council welcomes Craig, says goodbye to Purcell
The Louisa Town Council last week said hello to one member and goodbye to another.
At a special meeting Tuesday night, council voted 3-1 to appoint Graven Craig to temporarily fill the seat vacated by Daniel Crawford. Craig will serve until a special election in November to fill the remainder of Crawford’s term, which runs through 2028. Crawford resigned in March to move back to his native southwest Virginia.
Craig’s appointment was followed, at the end of the meeting, by the resignation of council’s longest-serving member: John Jerl Purcell IV. Purcell, who has been on council for nearly eight years, said that he resigned because he plans to move to a home outside the town limits.
In a letter of resignation shared at the meeting, Purcell said that it had been an honor to serve on the body and touted the town’s efforts to improve its utility infrastructure during his tenure.
“During my two terms, I have been grateful for the opportunity to contribute to several important initiatives. I am particularly proud of the progress made toward strengthening the financial stability of the town’s utility funds and advancing the continued improvement of both the water and sewer systems. Through engineered assessments and long-range planning, we have laid the groundwork for ongoing modernization of critical infrastructure, and I remain hopeful that these efforts will support the long-term health, resilience, and well-being of the community,” Purcell wrote.
Council instructed staff to advertise the vacancy and set a May 8 deadline for town residents to apply to temporarily fill the seat. Purcell’s term expires at the end of the year, and the seat is on the ballot this November.
Craig, council’s newest member, is well known to many town residents, having lived and raised a family in the community for more than 20 years and practiced law in the town for almost 30. He’s currently a partner in the Main Street law firm Craig Williams, where he litigates criminal and civil cases.
Craig also has deep roots in local Republican politics. He’s a former chair of the Louisa County Republican Committee and twice ran in Republican primaries of House of Delegates.
While Craig was the only citizen who applied to fill the vacancy, his appointment wasn’t without controversy and appeared to divide residents in the Tanyard neighborhood where he resides.
Rick Meyer, president of the Tanyard Property Owners Association (POA), submitted written comment just prior to Tuesday’s meeting, urging council not to select Craig. Meyer suggested that Craig had a conflict of interest because his law partner, attorney and developer Torrey Williams, is suing the town. The suit stems from council’s decision early last year to deny a special use permit that would’ve cleared the way for Williams to build a pair of duplexes on Barnstormer Circle across the street from other multi-family dwellings.
The property is, in part, owned by a company operated by Williams’ father, Toni Williams, who represents the Jackson District on the Louisa County Board of Supervisors.
“We have been trying for over two years to prevent duplexes [from] being built in our neighborhood. Thanks to council’s vote to deny a special use permit for the entity that Mr. Torrey Williams represented, we did. Mr. Willams has subsequently filed [a] suit against the town and the town council that is still pending [with] a court hearing June 1, the third postponement since last August. Mr. Craig is a law partner of Mr. Williams,” Meyer wrote.
Meyer wrote that Craig recently attended the Tanyard POA’s annual meeting where his actions “indicated that he would like to see the suit prevail.” According to Meyer, Craig derailed an effort by the POA to adopt restrictive covenants that would’ve prohibited new duplexes in the subdivision.
Meyer expressed concern that Craig wouldn’t be “impartial” in decisions about proposed development and its potential impact on residents and businesses.
“[Craig] has had no concerns or involvements in the past about the flooding issues, the sewer issues, traffic issues that we have had in our neighborhood. Now he wants to be on town council for 6 months,” Meyer wrote.
But two other Tanyard residents voiced support for Craig prior to Tuesday’s meeting with one praising his conduct at a recent POA meeting. In a letter, Diane McCourt said Craig had worked to deescalate tensions at the meeting and, in her view, exhibited the skills necessary to be an effective public servant.
“While I have not known Graven for a long period of time, I had the opportunity to meet him during a recent [POA] meeting where discussions around neighborhood guidelines became somewhat tense. What stood out to me was his ability to remain calm, thoughtful, and grounded in his approach. He consistently spoke in a rational and respectful manner, with a clear focus on finding common ground rather than escalating disagreement,” McCourt wrote. “In fact, he proactively offered to help form a collaborative group to bring different perspectives together and deescalate the situation; an approach that reflects the kind of leadership and temperament I believe is essential for public service.”
Before voting on the appointment, Council Member Roger Henry asked Craig about Meyer’s concerns. Craig said that he isn’t directly involved in Williams’ litigation, and he doesn’t believe it presents a conflict.
“I don’t have a conflict of interest in that particular matter because I have nothing to do with it other than that my law firm represents the parties that own the lots,” Craig said.
Craig also pushed back on Meyer’s contention that his action at the POA meeting indicated support for William’s lawsuit. He said that he merely offered his opinion that the town was unlikely to prevail in its effort to convince the court to dismiss the case based on the comments the judge made when he scheduled the hearing.
With respect to some residents’ push to amend the subdivision’s covenants to block duplexes, Craig said he advised the POA that the move could invite a legal challenge, noting there are already duplexes in Tanyard.
“He commented that I swayed some votes, and I’m glad I did because I’m trying to save the [POA] from litigation,” Craig said, adding, “I think that’s the one thing I bring to council. This is what I do for a living, and I, hopefully, can maybe head off some problems that we might walk into.”
Craig’s answers appeared to satisfy most council members. Henry, Purcell and Sylvia Rigsby voted in favor of his appointment while Tanyard resident Vicky Harte opposed.
Click here for contact information for the Louisa County Board of Supervisors.
Find agendas and minutes from previous Board of Supervisors and Planning Commission meetings as well as archived recordings here.
Click here for contact information for the Louisa County School Board.
Click here for minutes and agendas for School Board meetings. Click here for archived video.
Click here to access past editions of Engage Louisa.


Keep in mind that not all members of the Bumpass Residents page necessarily live in the Jackson District, and many that post politically, are on other 'resident' type pages as well.